2192 - Crafting a Smart Marketing Strategy in a Tech-Driven World with Butler Marketing Group's Sheila Butler

Business Growth & Scaling| Marketing & Branding| Leadership

May 27, 2025•3 min read

Unlocking Marketing Success with Sheila Butler: Fractional CMOs, AI, and Brand Transformation

Custom HTML/CSS/JAVASCRIPT

In this episode of The Thoughtful Entrepreneur, host Josh Elledge welcomes Sheila Butler, Founder and Chief Marketing Officer of Butler Marketing Group. Sheila brings decades of experience to the table and shares her sharp insights on the evolving role of fractional CMOs, the impact of AI in marketing, and the enduring power of brand storytelling. Whether you're a founder scaling up or a CMO seeking clarity, this conversation is packed with actionable strategies and modern marketing wisdom.

Marketing with Personality: From Disney Dreams to Brand Strategy

Sheila Butler’s love for storytelling and customer experience was inspired by her childhood dream of working for Disney—an aspiration that shaped her career in entertainment, marketing, and branding. Now based in Orlando, just a short drive from Disney parks, Sheila taps into that creative energy and sense of wonder to help businesses craft brands that truly connect.

Her newest venture, a YouTube series called Marketing Over Bourbon, blends her professional expertise with her personable style. Sheila uses the show to share marketing insights, industry best practices, and commentary on emerging trends—all with a casual, conversational tone. It’s a reflection of her approach to marketing: human, insightful, and always evolving.

She also dives into the rise of AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini in her work—emphasizing that marketers shouldn’t fear these tools but embrace them to improve productivity and creative output. Through experimentation, she identifies which AI applications best support each client’s unique goals. Combined with her hands-on role as a fractional CMO, Sheila provides strategic execution—not just advice—to businesses undergoing transformation.

About Sheila Butler

Sheila Butler is an accomplished Chief Marketing Officer with over 25 years of experience in brand transformation, marketing strategy, loyalty program design, and partnership marketing across both B2C and B2B sectors. She has held key leadership roles at Disney, JPMorgan Chase, Choice Hotels, and Axiom Bank. As the Founder and CMO of Butler Marketing Group in Orlando, Florida, Sheila partners with organizations to solve complex marketing challenges and deliver measurable brand growth through customer insights, CRM, and storytelling.

About Butler Marketing Group

Butler Marketing Group partners with businesses in transition—helping them evolve their brand, align marketing efforts with business goals, and adopt new technologies like AI to enhance content creation and strategy. Whether serving as a fractional CMO or collaborating with internal teams, the agency brings both clarity and execution to the table.

Links Mentioned in this Episode:

Episode Highlights:

What sets a fractional CMO apart from traditional marketing consultants
How to apply AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini to enhance marketing workflows
Why brand transformation is essential in times of business change
The power of continuous learning and creating engaging content
Sheila’s success story guiding a brand merger during a private equity deal

Conclusion

Sheila Butler delivers clear, modern insights into what it takes to lead marketing in today’s business landscape. From embracing AI and building a strong brand identity to knowing when to bring in a fractional CMO, her advice is practical and timely. If you're a business leader navigating growth, change, or complexity, Sheila’s strategies can help you sharpen your message and amplify your results.

Apply to be a Guest on The Thoughtful Entrepreneur: https://go.upmyinfluence.com/podcast-guest

More from UpMyInfluence:
We are actively booking guests for our The Thoughtful Entrepreneur. Schedule HERE.
Are you a 6-figure consultant? I’ve got high-level intros for you. Learn more here.
What is your #1 Lead Generation BLOCKER? Take my free quiz here.
Want to learn more about all the podcasts managed by UpMyInfluence? Opt in here.

Don’t forget to subscribe to The Thoughtful Entrepreneur and thank you for listening. Tune in next time!

Josh Elledge

Josh Elledge is U.S. Navy veteran who became a serial entrepreneur who builds the companies he needs most in the world. In 2014, He launched UpMyInfluence to help entrepreneurs like himself attract the perfect audiences and grow their authority and influence. However, while growing their better-than-PR agency, UpMyInfluence discovered that building 7-figure B2B Sales Systems for consultants and agencies (with zero paid advertising) is actually what they do better than anyone else on the planet. UMI was the natural outgrowth of his first startup, SavingsAngel.com which had grown to more than 50 employees and grossed more than $6 million in sales with zero paid ads. He did it all through building authority and serving audiences in the media. Josh is a frequent speaker at business and startup conferences including Social Media Marketing World and a Tony Robbins event for his Business Mastery grads. He’s a weekly consumer expert on Fox 35 Orlando and News 13, writes a syndicated column for nine newspapers (with total readership above 1.1 million readers), and regularly appears on more than 75 TV stations across the country. All told, Josh has appeared in the media more than 2500 times. Passionate about his family, physical fitness (an avid fitness geek and 5K to marathon runner), and breaking out of Escape Rooms, Josh now lives in Orlando with his wife and three children.

Back to Blog